Advent 3B: Asking the right questions

Isaiah 61:1-4, 8-11; 1 Thessalonians, 5:16-24, John 1:6-8, 19-28

In this week’s gospel, the priests, Levites and Pharisees have many questions for John the Baptist. As leaders, they want to know whether they should endorse John and join him or denounce and avoid him.  They are doing their due diligence. Exactly what Paul tells us to do in the reading from Thessalonians: “Test everything. Keep what is good. Abstain from evil.”

When we are trying to decide if something is good or evil, the questions we ask make a difference. They reveal whether we are looking for the truth or looking for an excuse.

Since before November, we have known that the best way to protect health care workers, essential workers, our friends and neighbors and the economy was to stay home when possible, social distance and wear a mask.

Thousands of people did not like that reality, so they asked other questions: can I go home for Thanksgiving if I get a test? Which test? Will it be ok if we keep the dining room windows open? We’ve probably all seen the pictures of airports filled with crowds of people waiting in line standing shoulder to shoulder.

Before that, since May, a Republican Senate has refused to consider the HEROES Act which had been passed by the House. That measure would have helped stabilize the economy by protecting small businesses and the unemployed. The questions which the Republican senators asked were about their own re-election prospects, not the welfare of their constituents.          

The questions we ask make all the difference. They reveal whether we are looking for the truth or for an excuse.

Womanist theology suggests that the questions we ask should be about “justice, survival and quality of life.” [1] And not just for those of us who are privileged because we are white, male, heterosexual, able-bodied, pensioned and/or able-to-work-or-study-from-home.  We should be asking about “justice, survival and quality of life” from the perspective of those who are least-advantaged. These days, our questions should come from the perspective of…

  • People living in nursing homes which have a higher percentages of Black or Hispanic residents. They are more likely to contract Covid and die, according to an analysis by the Kaiser Family Foundation. Tampa Bay Times, 11/11/20 and The New York Times, 9/10/20, and     
  • African-American direct care workers. They make up approximately 30 percent of the 4.5 million personal care aides, home health aides and nursing assistants working in private homes, group homes, residential care facilities, assisted living facilities, continuing care retirement facilities, nursing care facilities and hospitals. PHI Research Brief, February 6, 2018. Studies show that health care workers are at increased risk for exposure and infection relative to the general population. [2]

We may not like the answers to these questions. It may mean that this year at Christmas there will be no family visits, no church or pageant, no Santa Claus, no gifts, no fun. Hopefully, we can remember that the anointed one speaking in Isaiah says that God’s message of good news is for the oppressed and the brokenhearted. May we do what we can to help bring that message to fruition.

Next week: Advent 4 & Movement 4 – A challenge to the existing order.

[1] Monica A. Coleman’s postmodern Womanist vision of “Making a Way Out of No Way” entails: (1)God’s presentation of unforeseen possibilities, (2) human agency, (3) the goals of justice, survival and quality of life and (4) a challenge to the existing order. Making a Way Out of No Way: A Womanist Theology, (Fortress Press, Minneapolis, MN.) 2008 at 93.

[2] KFF, Racial Equity and Health Policy, November 11, 2020.

Photo: Badge ID of Deborah Gatewood, a phlebotomist at Beaumont Hospital, Detroit, for 30 years. She died of Covid-related symptoms on April 17, 2020 after having been denied a Covid test 4 different times by the hospital at which she worked.

Advent 2B – Acting to find a way out of no way.

Isaiah 40: 1-11, 2 Peter 3:8-15a, Mark 1:1-8

Rosa Parks was an activist before her famous bus ride on December 1, 1955. She had taken training at the Highlander Folk School in Tennessee and she was secretary of the Montgomery and Alabama chapters of the NAACP. She was part of an inner circle of prominent Black leaders in Montgomery.

For Parks and her fellow civil rights activists the project of ending the oppression of Jim Crow and achieving civil rights equality was huge. Daunting. Overwhelming. It was hard to know what strategy would have the best chance of success.  One idea being discussed was a one-day bus boycott to protest the way Black riders were treated on segregated buses.

A decade earlier, in 1944, a 35-year-old Black woman, Viola White, had refused to give up her seat on the bus.  On that day in 1944, she may not have been thinking of her situation as a constitutional test case. She may simply have wanted to get home and avoid being put off the bus at the wrong stop  –  an illegal tactic even under Jim Crow but frequently employed by Montgomery bus drivers. More likely, she knew that the bus driver was wrong, that she was within her rights to keep her seat, and that she was entitled to have her rights respected.  He told her to move. She kept her seat. 

Womanist theology has roots in Black, feminist and liberation theologies but it is grounded in the unique experience and spirituality of Black women.  It focuses on the goal of survival.1 Salvation is not about life-after-death. It is about surviving in the here and now. Sometimes, the only way to survive is to “Make a way out of no way.” Black women in particular often face death-dealing circumstances in which there appears to be “no way.” 

In mid-century Montgomery, Black women faced the legacy of 244 years of Black enslavement, 50 years of Jim Crow and the fact that the only way to go to work and back was on a bus driven by a racist man who would be backed by the police. Where was “the way” in those circumstances?

In her 2008 book, Making a Way Out of No Way, Womanist theologian Monica Coleman choreographs the interaction between God and humanity on the way to salvation.  In the first of four movements, God presents us with many unforeseen possibilities.

In the second movement, we have to act. Movement 2 is about human agency. “Agency” is a philosophical term which refers to our capacity to act in the world. If we have agency, we are not merely reacting to outside forces. We see, we evaluate, we decide and we act. Our acting is a participation in the movement towards salvation.  As the author of 2 Peter says in this week’s second reading: Be glad that God has delayed “the day of the Lord.” God’s patience gives you yet another chance to act. So do something.

What we decide to do may seem inadequate compared to the huge obstacles injustice creates. But if our acting enables us to survive in the face of death-dealing circumstances, it is right and it is sufficient.  And God will use it to make a way where it seemed there was no way.

Viola White died ten years after her action on the bus. The appeal of her arrest and conviction was never heard by the courts. But shortly after her death, on March 2, 1955, 15-year-old Claudette Colvin refused to give up her seat. By this time, activists were thinking about constitutional test cases and were planning for a one-day boycott. Soon thereafter, bus rider Aurelia Browder was arrested on April 29, 1955. Mary Louise Smith and Susie McDonald were arrested on October 21, and Rosa Parks was arrested on December 1, 1955.

Park’s arrest was a last straw.  It ignited the planned one-day boycott. Because of Mrs. White’s experience, the lawyers knew better how to prepare the legal case. They filed in federal court on behalf of four of the bus riders and the case was heard in the U.S. Supreme Court. Browder v. Gayle2 held that said the segregation laws were unconstitutional. The planned one-day bus boycott had lasted 381 days and brought a young Black minister to national attention… Martin Luther King, Jr.

“Once we act, God works with what we have offered to God and to the world in order to influence us in the next moment. God is always working with what the world has to offer.”3

Next week: Advent 3 and Movement 3 – The goals of survival, justice and quality of life.

Photo: Walking to work during the boycott

1 Black and liberation theologies focus on the Exodus story and its liberation theme. Womanist theology looks to the story of Hagar (Genesis 16 & 21) in which God offers possibilities for survival. Hagar’s story is central in Delores S. Williams’ landmark book, Sisters in the Wilderness: The Challenge of Womanist God-talk, (Orbis Books, Maryknoll, NY 1993.)

2 William Armistead “Tacky” Gayle, Jr. was the mayor of Montgomery, Alabama, from 1951 to 1959.

3 Monica A. Coleman, Making a Way Out of No Way: A Womanist Theology, (Fortress Press:Minneapolis, MN ) 2008, at 74.